Here’s a dirty little secret that could ruin me from a marketing perspective but I don’t care. I’m a proud generalist. When I look at my caseload, my youngest client is 9 and the oldest is 65. I know this isn’t ideal to admit as the common advice is to “niche down”. I have gone through stages, usually out of anxiety, where I created bios that said things like “I work with Black male, first-time fathers, who struggle with racial identity concerns and have experienced three childhood traumas.” I am sure this is great for SEO but it is not genuine to me.
I see clients of all backgrounds. This does not mean, however, that I work with everyone. That would be inaccurate. It just means that I do not turn people away merely because they don’t fit a carefully curated category. My 15-minute consultation is not a marketing ploy to get clients in the door. I take it seriously and only take on clients that I believe I can help. If not, I simply refer people out.
My “rule,” for lack of better words, is to accept people unless they present with a concern that I do not have extensive training in (i.e., eating disorders, personality disorders, etc.). I have found that certain people would benefit from a specialist and I am more than happy to refer them to one. I am trained in approaches like CBT and EMDR but I don’t only work with people who have experienced trauma or distorted thinking. Here is how I developed my stance:
Suffering is suffering
I have had the opportunity to work in psychiatric settings, outpatient clinics, colleges, and private practice. The one lesson I learned from all my experience—spanning close to a decade—is that suffering is suffering. Most people deal with a variety of life stressors and can benefit from an empathic therapist who genuinely cares. They don’t necessarily need to work with someone who can recite diagnostic criteria. Having someone who truly works to understand you often makes the difference between feeling stuck and moving forward.
Everyone’s experience of suffering is different
I have never seen two people with depression, anxiety or trauma that presented the same way. Every person I have had the pleasure of helping has presented their own unique puzzle that I had to figure out. This is why the most well-intentioned “treatment modalities” and “interventions” can fall flat.
I once tried EMDR with a client who had endured multiple tragedies, and it didn’t work. On the other hand, I’ve had clients who considered EMDR a miracle. The truth is: no single approach works for everyone.
Connection matters most
This sounds cheesy but follow me. The success of talk therapy depends on how open a person feels they can be with their therapist. Feeling silenced, dismissed, or judged by your therapist usually slows down your progress or halts it all together. We are more likely to be open and vulnerable with someone we connect with. If the therapist also happens to share a unique niche—let’s say, businessmen who ballroom dance and watch anime—even better. But connection is what matters most.
People rarely present with one problem
If people had more insight, they would say that they are interested in “therapy for anxiety, depression, trauma, and stress” more often. Stress doesn’t just happen in a vacuum. The presenting concern is often just the tip of the iceberg. This is where a generalist shines: addressing the whole person, not just the symptom. As a side note, this is also why the practice is named NY Wellness in lieu of Trauma Clinic of New York.
At the risk of sounding like a broken record, I’ll say it again: therapy is not like going to a person that specializes in knee surgery. Marketing would have us think it is but it’s not true. Therapy is most effective when you like and trust your therapist. The more you like, and trust your therapist, the more you share. The more you share, the more you offer a true window into thoughts, feelings, and patterns that may resolve the puzzle of your distress.
I am not saying to stick with a therapist just because you like them. You still have to see progress (as you define it). I don’t automatically trust interventions that I have used in the past with other people. Instead, I regularly check in with clients to ensure that they feel like they are making progress.
At NY Wellness, we believe therapy works best when it’s about connection, not categories. We’re proud generalists who meet people where they are, whether they’re navigating anxiety, trauma, or simply the stresses of everyday life. Learn more about our team here, or if you’re ready, schedule a free consultation.
