Who Told You That You Weren’t Man Enough?

What does it mean to be “man enough”? A therapist reflects on masculinity, intimidation, strength, and what happens when we stop trying to prove ourselves.

A reflection on masculinity, intimidation, and the kind of strength that makes people feel safe

“Do you think other men think this way?”

A man I was working with asked me this while describing how he felt around other men he perceived as domineering. He was generally quiet in their presence and paid close attention to what they said and did. He worried about how they might respond if he challenged them, and sometimes found himself wondering whether he could defend himself if a situation became physical.

It was troubling both because he felt uncomfortable around them and because of what he believed that discomfort said about him. He worried that becoming quiet and watchful meant that he was less of a man.

I understood more of his experience than he probably realized.

There was a period in my life when I was fascinated by gangs and drawn to men who seemed capable of intimidating just about anyone. I admired their confidence, their apparent fearlessness, and the way they could command a room. I remember one person boasting that he could make one phone call and have dozens of people waiting on a corner. I found that impressive. Knowing that you had that kind of influence and that people would think twice about challenging you seemed powerful to me.

When Kindness Starts to Feel Like a Liability

As a kid, I was sensitive and quick to cry. My father once told me something to the effect of, “You’re a great kid, but you’re too soft,” or perhaps that I was too sensitive. I can’t remember his exact words, but I remember what I took from them.

He would also ask me about my experiences with girls, and I remember feeling as though I didn’t measure up to other boys around me. Taken together, those messages left me with the sense that there were parts of me that needed to change if I was going to become the kind of man I thought I was supposed to be.

I want to be careful about how I tell this story because I love my father, and we have a great relationship today. I speak with him every day. He also came from an unstable childhood and grew up in circumstances that could be very rough. He had seen things I had not seen. When he encouraged me to toughen up, I believe part of what he was trying to communicate was practical. He didn’t want people taking advantage of me.

When I was 14, I was robbed. That experience intensified a lot of what I was already feeling. The possibility of being physically overpowered wasn’t theoretical anymore, and I became even more determined to make myself into someone other people would think twice about threatening.

I worked very hard to change myself. I practiced intimidating expressions in the mirror and repeated violent things to myself. I deliberately exposed myself to disturbing material because I believed a tough man should be able to tolerate brutality without flinching. I admired men who seemed willing to go further than everyone else, and I tried to convince myself that I could go even further. At one point, I became convinced that I would probably end up in jail someday. That was how far I had taken this idea of who I needed to become. I was trying to make myself into someone nobody would mistake for weak.

Eventually, I developed a stern, almost threatening expression that became my default way of carrying myself. People would regularly ask whether I was okay or why I looked upset, even when nothing was wrong. At first, that was close to the effect I wanted. I believed that if I looked intimidating enough, people would be less likely to bother me.

The worst part was how difficult it became to let go of that expression when I no longer wanted to carry myself that way. I began making a conscious effort to soften how I presented myself, but people continued asking what was wrong. Eventually, those questions started to annoy me. Here I was trying to change, and people kept reminding me of this habit I had created.

I don’t carry myself that way anymore, although I can still put on that expression if I want to. Looking back, I can see that it was born out of a genuine desire to feel safe. I wanted to know that I could stand up for myself and that other people would think twice before threatening me. Somewhere along the way, I began confusing the ability to protect myself with the ability to frighten other people.

The Men I Admired Did Not Always Make Me Feel Safe

For all the power I associated with those men, being around some of them could be exhausting.

I often felt I needed to watch what I said because an ordinary comment might be interpreted as disrespect. I worried that somebody might suddenly become confrontational, and I sometimes felt pressure to demonstrate that I was willing to get involved if a fight broke out.

There was also the quieter pressure of appearing interested in the things other men seemed to bond over. I have boxed and played a little basketball, but I have never enjoyed sitting down to watch sports on television. I find it incredibly boring. Around certain men, even admitting something like that could feel like one more way to invite questions about whether I measured up.

Of course, being loud, physically imposing, competitive, or assertive doesn’t make someone dangerous. I’ve known men with those qualities who were thoughtful and dependable. What unsettled me was the unpredictability of men who seemed to interpret ordinary disagreements as challenges to their masculinity and who might escalate a situation rather than tolerate feeling disrespected.

There is a substantial body of psychological research examining these kinds of masculine norms. Masculinity isn’t one universally agreed-upon set of characteristics. Ideas about how men are supposed to behave are influenced by families, peers, communities, and cultures, and they can include expectations around toughness, emotional control, self-reliance, dominance, and sexual behavior.

That helps explain something I didn’t understand when I was younger. I thought these men were refusing to conform. They seemed to live by their own rules and didn’t appear to care what anybody thought about them. Looking back, some of them were conforming just as much as everyone else. They were simply conforming to a different set of rules.

You can’t appear afraid. You can’t let someone disrespect you. You can’t back down. You have to be successful with women. You have to be interested in certain things. You can’t let another man think he’s tougher than you.

Doesn’t that sound like a box to you?

As I’ve gotten older, I’ve begun to question whether the ability to intimidate someone is as necessary as I once believed. If another person can reliably provoke you into losing control by making you feel disrespected, they’ve discovered a button they can use to manipulate you.

I spent years associating strength with the willingness to go further than other people. I’ve become more interested in the ability to recognize when going further would only make things worse.

A Different Kind of Power

My understanding of masculinity also changed through relationships with men who led differently.

One of them was a former boss of mine. He wasn’t aggressive or intimidating. There was a softness about him. When he became excited about explaining something, he might stumble over his words a little, but he was knowledgeable, patient, and generous with what he knew.

I felt safe working with him.

If I made a mistake or didn’t understand something, I could ask him about it. He took time to teach me, and I trusted that he wanted me to develop rather than feel small in his presence. I respected him tremendously, and if I ever returned to that line of work, he’s the kind of person I’d want to work with again.

For years, I had admired men because of the fear they could generate. Here was a man I respected because of how safe he made me feel.

I didn’t stop valuing leadership or strength after working with him. I started thinking differently about what those things could look like. Someone could have authority without constantly asserting it. A person could be capable of protecting others while also making room for them to ask questions and grow.

Today, as I lead my own counseling practice and supervise clinicians, I think about that experience. I want the people who work with me to feel comfortable bringing me a difficult question or admitting that they don’t know something. I want them to know that I’ll take their concerns seriously and help them grow.

Who Would You Trust Enough to Fall Asleep Beside?

In session, my client and I talked about what being a man meant to him. He mentioned leadership and strength, and I wondered about safety. Could someone protect others while also making them feel safe?

I asked him to picture a long car ride with two different drivers.

One driver is impulsive and easily provoked. If another driver cuts him off or disrespects him, he may follow the person, pull over, or escalate the situation into a confrontation. He’s perfectly willing to fight. The problem is that you don’t know what you’re going to wake up to. Maybe you make it to your destination without a problem. Or maybe you wake up because he has gotten into a road-rage incident, the police are surrounding the car, or his attention has shifted from driving safely to proving something to another driver.

The other driver can defend himself if a situation genuinely requires it, but he doesn’t feel compelled to respond to every provocation. He pays attention to what is happening around him, uses judgment, and focuses on getting both of you safely to your destination.

I asked my client which car he could imagine falling asleep in.

He chose the second. I would too.

He also reflected on experiences from his own life that had left him feeling on edge around unpredictability. The conversation gave us another way of thinking about what he had previously been calling masculinity. Maybe his tendency to become watchful around certain men didn’t automatically mean he was deficient. Maybe there was information in that response worth paying attention to.

The point isn’t that a man should always back down. I believe people should be able to protect themselves. There are circumstances in which protecting yourself or someone else requires direct action. I also think situational awareness, communication, and de-escalation can prevent many situations from ever reaching that point.

Being capable of acting and feeling obligated to prove that capability at every opportunity are very different things.

Strength Without the Performance

I still believe in developing strength. I don’t think people benefit from arranging their entire lives around avoiding discomfort.

I often think about this through the example of resistance training, although I don’t mean only lifting weights. Resistance is part of ordinary life. There are mornings when I don’t feel like following my routine. There are difficult conversations I would rather avoid and feelings I would prefer not to sit with. Sometimes I’m bored and want immediate stimulation. Sometimes I simply don’t feel like doing something I know is important.

I haven’t mastered any of this myself. I’m trying to become better at tolerating that resistance without needing the discomfort to disappear before I act.

I want to be disciplined and responsible. I want to show up when I say I will. I want people to feel safe in my presence, and I want to be able to respond when someone needs my help. I want to be kind without being easily taken advantage of.

I don’t know whether strength, discipline, dependability, restraint, and leadership belong uniquely to men. I do know they are central to the kind of man I want to be.

Different men will have different areas in which they need to grow. A reserved man may need to become more assertive. Someone who is quick to confront people may need to become better at regulating himself. Someone who avoids discomfort may need to become more willing to sit in it.

There are good reasons to develop all of those capacities without turning them into rites of passage for manhood.

That strength isn’t always visible, and it doesn’t always get rewarded in the moment. Sometimes it looks like holding your tongue when you could say something harsh or letting someone else save face when you could embarrass them. Sometimes it’s apologizing when you’d rather double down. None of that is flashy, but it takes more strength than it gets credit for.

What Are We Trying to Prove?

I still catch myself measuring against old scripts. There’s a part of me that thinks I should like watching sports even though I don’t. Some of the things I actually enjoy are journaling, working on my aquariums, deep dives into clinical problems, and exploring the mechanics of firearms.

None of that proves anything. It’s just me.

I’ve also had the privilege of sitting with many men in therapy, including men who present themselves as exceptionally confident or tough. I’ve heard men who appear very different from one another talk about rejection, sexuality, relationships, inadequacy, loneliness, the possibility of being hurt, and the fear that they don’t measure up.

I wouldn’t say every man has the same fears or that every confident man is secretly insecure. I’ve simply learned that a man’s outward presentation tells me far less about his inner life than I once assumed.

A man may be comfortable in a fight and deeply uncomfortable discussing a relationship. Another may communicate beautifully but become frightened when someone raises their voice at him. Someone can be tremendously successful professionally and feel completely inadequate romantically.

We have also developed a strange habit of trying to settle questions about masculinity by appealing to some imagined ancestral man. Maybe men evolved to do this, or cavemen had to do that. Even if a particular behavior offered some advantage in an ancestral environment, that doesn’t automatically tell us how a man should behave today. Modern life asks a great deal of our judgment, impulse control, communication, and ability to cooperate with other people.

I’m not interested in replacing one performance with another, like now, “real men cry,” or “real men do X.” I’m not trying to trade one script for another. I’m trying to live without the script.

If other people’s reactions decide how you move, it is essentially mental confinement.

That applies to the reserved man who thinks he needs to become intimidating, but I think it can also apply to the man who identifies strongly with being dominant, fearless, or “alpha.” Maybe those qualities genuinely fit him. The question is whether he feels free to be anything else when the situation calls for it. Can he admit uncertainty? Can he allow someone else to lead? Can he tolerate rejection or accept care without feeling as though something has been taken from him?

When your identity has to be maintained at all times, you don’t have much room to move.

The question I find myself asking now isn’t, “What makes a real man?”

It’s, “What happens when I stop auditioning?”

That takes me back to the man who originally asked whether other men think the way he does. He had been looking at men who were more domineering than he was and using them as a measuring stick. The more useful question may be why their way of being became the standard he believed he had to meet.

There may still be things he wants to work on. Maybe he wants to become more assertive, more comfortable with conflict, or more confident in his ability to protect himself. Those can all be worthwhile goals. Meaningful therapy can include examining where those goals came from, what they mean to him, and whether they actually serve the life he wants to live.

He doesn’t have to pursue them to pass a masculinity test.

There are worthwhile reasons to become stronger, more disciplined, more assertive, and more comfortable with discomfort. There are worthwhile reasons to learn how to protect yourself and the people you love.

Proving that you are a man does not have to be one of them.

Book a Free Initial Consultation

Individual Therapy in New Jersey & New York

Ready to take the next step? Let’s start this journey together!