One question I frequently hear from people considering therapy is, “What am I supposed to talk about?”
It’s a reasonable question. Most conversations in our lives have a purpose. We call someone to share news, meet a colleague to discuss work, or speak with a friend about something that’s bothering us. Therapy is a little different. You’re setting aside time to talk about yourself with someone you barely know, without necessarily knowing what you want to say.
Even people who have been in therapy for years sometimes sit down and find themselves at a loss for words.
I think some of that uncertainty comes from the expectation that therapy requires a problem worth discussing. People assume they should arrive with something significant, an important realization, or at least an update on whatever brought them into counseling. But some of the most meaningful conversations I’ve had with clients began without any particular direction.
The good news is that you don’t need to know exactly what to talk about in therapy before you begin. Your therapist can help you find a starting point, and sometimes the process of figuring out what matters is an important part of the work itself.
How I Found Myself in Therapy
When I was in graduate school at Columbia, several of my professors encouraged us to experience therapy ourselves. Their reasoning was straightforward: if we wanted to become good therapists, we should understand what it felt like to sit on the other side of the room.
So I went.
I wasn’t in crisis, and I didn’t have a diagnosis I wanted someone to fix. I was curious about the experience and wanted to understand myself better.
What surprised me was how much I had to say once I stopped trying to say it correctly. I remember talking for most of that first session and leaving with a sense of relief I hadn’t expected.
That experience still shapes how I think about therapy. I don’t believe someone needs to be in distress to benefit from understanding themselves, and I certainly don’t think they need to know what to talk about before they arrive.
Much of my work today involves helping people explore their relationships, understand recurring patterns, and develop a deeper appreciation for who they are. Anxiety, depression, and other concerns may be part of those conversations, but therapy does not always have to revolve around reducing a particular symptom.
Sometimes the work is simply about getting to know yourself better.
Start With What Happened This Week
When someone tells me they don’t know what to discuss, I sometimes suggest walking through their week. We might begin with something as ordinary as a frustrating interaction at work or a moment with a partner. What interests me isn’t necessarily the event itself, but how the person experienced it, what stayed with them, and what we might discover by becoming curious about their reaction.
A disagreement with your partner might lead to a conversation about expectations or communication. Something that happened at work could reveal how much importance you place on being liked or respected. Even a seemingly uneventful week can offer an opportunity to examine your routines, relationships, and general satisfaction with life.
Of course, not everything needs to have a deeper psychological meaning. Sometimes a frustrating interaction is simply frustrating, and an uneventful week is just that.
The point is that you don’t have to determine whether an experience is important enough to discuss before bringing it into therapy. You and your therapist can explore that together.
I find that people often underestimate how much of their emotional lives unfolds in seemingly ordinary moments. We spend much of our time working, interacting with others, making decisions, and responding to situations without giving much thought to why we respond as we do.
Therapy gives us an opportunity to slow down and examine some of those experiences more carefully.
You Don’t Have to Organize Your Thoughts Before Speaking
There’s a concept in psychotherapy called free association, which involves allowing thoughts to emerge without immediately filtering, organizing, or judging them.
Although it is traditionally associated with psychoanalysis, I think the underlying idea can be useful for anyone who struggles to figure out what to say in therapy.
In everyday conversations, we constantly decide what information is relevant, interesting, appropriate, or worth sharing. We try to stay on topic, avoid awkwardness, and make sure the other person understands where we’re going.
Therapy can offer a different kind of conversation.
You might begin talking about work and find yourself remembering an interaction with your father. A conversation about a friendship could bring up something that happened years ago. You may notice that you keep returning to a particular concern, even though you originally intended to discuss something completely different.
Rather than immediately redirecting yourself, it can be worthwhile to explore where those thoughts are taking you.
This doesn’t mean every therapy session should be unstructured. Some people benefit from specific goals, planned exercises, or a more directive approach, particularly when addressing certain mental health conditions.
But if you’re interested in exploratory therapy, you don’t necessarily need to arrive with an organized account of everything you want to discuss. Sometimes allowing yourself to speak before you have fully figured out what you mean can lead to a more meaningful conversation.
Sometimes You Know What You Want to Say, but You’re Afraid to Say It
There is an important difference between not knowing what to talk about and knowing exactly what you want to discuss but feeling uncomfortable bringing it up.
People sometimes avoid certain topics because they’re concerned about what their thoughts or feelings might reveal about them.
They may experience anger toward someone they love, feel jealous of a friend, have sexual thoughts they find embarrassing, or struggle with intrusive thoughts that seem inconsistent with their values.
Others worry about how their therapist might respond to their political beliefs, religious views, or feelings toward the therapist themselves.
I’ve written about this more extensively in my article, “I’d Never Tell My Therapist That”, which explores why people sometimes withhold the very experiences they might benefit from discussing.
One thing I emphasize in my work is that having a thought or feeling does not necessarily tell us everything about the person experiencing it.
I am generally more interested in understanding what an experience means to someone than immediately deciding what it says about their character.
If you’re struggling to bring something up, you can even begin by discussing your hesitation. Telling your therapist that there’s something you want to talk about but feel embarrassed to share can be a useful starting point.
You don’t have to disclose everything immediately. Trust takes time, and a good therapist should respect that.
It’s Okay to Talk About the Same Thing Again
Another concern I sometimes hear from clients is that they feel embarrassed about revisiting something we’ve already discussed.
They might apologize for bringing up a previous relationship, returning to a family conflict, or continuing to struggle with something they believe they should have resolved by now.
I don’t see repetition as inherently problematic.
Understanding something intellectually doesn’t necessarily mean it stops affecting us emotionally. Someone may recognize that a relationship was unhealthy and still miss the person. Another individual may understand why they seek approval from others but continue to feel distressed when they perceive rejection.
We also encounter familiar experiences differently as our lives change.
A conversation about your parents at age twenty-five may feel quite different when you’re thirty-five and raising children of your own. An experience you previously dismissed might take on new meaning after a significant relationship or life transition.
Sometimes returning to a familiar subject allows us to recognize something we weren’t able to appreciate before.
Of course, if you feel as though you’re discussing the same issue repeatedly without gaining anything from it, that is worth talking about too. Your therapist can help you consider whether a different approach might be useful.
Your Relationship With Your Therapist Is Also Worth Discussing
One of the more interesting aspects of therapy is that the relationship between the client and therapist can become part of the work.
People sometimes assume therapy should focus exclusively on their lives outside the session. However, how you experience your therapist can offer valuable information about how you relate to other people.
You might find yourself worrying about whether your therapist approves of you, hesitating to disagree with something they’ve said, or feeling uncomfortable when they ask a particular question.
You might also notice that you feel unusually comfortable with your therapist, appreciate something they said during a previous session, or find yourself wondering what they think about you.
These experiences are worth discussing.
For someone who struggles with confrontation, telling a therapist that they disagreed with an observation can be significant. Someone who fears disappointing others might discover that they are also trying to be the ideal client, carefully selecting what to share to avoid being judged.
The therapeutic relationship offers an opportunity to explore some of these patterns while they are actually happening.
You can also ask your therapist questions. You might want to understand why they asked something, what they noticed during a conversation, or how they make sense of an experience you’ve described.
Therapists vary in how much personal information they share, and there are legitimate professional boundaries around self-disclosure. However, asking questions and expressing curiosity about the person you’re working with are not inherently inappropriate.
In my experience, some of the most useful conversations arise when clients feel comfortable enough to tell me what they are actually experiencing in our relationship.
What if You Don’t Think Therapy Is Helping?
This is another subject I wish more people felt comfortable discussing.
If you’ve been attending therapy and don’t feel as though you’re benefiting, I encourage you to bring that concern directly to your therapist.
You might feel that your sessions lack direction, that you’re spending too much time discussing certain subjects, or that you would benefit from more practical guidance. Alternatively, you may feel that your therapist is moving too quickly toward solutions when you would prefer more time to explore your experiences.
These are all reasonable concerns.
As therapists, we have clinical training and expertise, but we aren’t mind readers. We can misunderstand what someone needs, become overly focused on a particular issue, or fail to recognize that our approach isn’t resonating with the person we’re trying to help.
I would much rather have a client tell me that something isn’t working than have them continue attending sessions out of politeness.
Sometimes those conversations lead us to adjust our approach. Other times, we discover that a different form of therapy or another clinician might be a better fit.
Either way, I think being able to discuss the process openly is an important part of a healthy therapeutic relationship.
What About Silence?
Silence is another thing people sometimes find uncomfortable in therapy.
We’re accustomed to conversations where pauses get filled quickly. When someone stops speaking, we often assume that somebody needs to say something to keep the interaction moving. However, silence can serve an important purpose.
One thing I’ve learned as a therapist is that silence doesn’t necessarily mean a session has stalled. I discovered that unexpectedly when I temporarily lost much of my voice and had to speak less during sessions.
Because speaking was difficult, I became more selective about when I intervened. What surprised me was how often clients used that additional space to arrive at their own insights.
I wrote about that experience in “Radical Listening Is the Secret Ingredient to Successful Psychotherapy”.
It reinforced something I still value: sometimes our role as therapists is to create the conditions for someone to discover what’s important for themselves.
This doesn’t mean a therapist should simply sit silently while a client struggles to find something to say. There are certainly times when asking a question, offering an observation, or providing direction is helpful.
But I think we sometimes underestimate how much can happen when people are given enough room to think.
If you find yourself sitting quietly during a session, you don’t necessarily have to rush to fill the space. You can take a moment to consider what you’re feeling, what you’re thinking about, or what makes the silence uncomfortable in the first place.
Even saying, “I feel awkward because I don’t know what to say right now,” gives you and your therapist something to explore.
You Don’t Have to Be Good at Therapy
Ultimately, I think people sometimes place unnecessary pressure on themselves to do therapy correctly.
They want to choose the right topic, communicate their thoughts clearly, and make sure they’re using their time productively.
I understand those concerns. Therapy requires time, money, and emotional energy, and it’s reasonable to want something meaningful in return.
But I don’t believe meaningful therapy requires every session to feel profound.
Sometimes a conversation meanders. Sometimes you leave with a new understanding of yourself, while other times you may not immediately recognize what you gained from the experience. And sometimes a session genuinely doesn’t feel particularly helpful, which is also something you can discuss with your therapist.
The goal isn’t to perform therapy successfully. It’s to participate in a process that helps you better understand yourself and make meaningful changes in your life.
I sometimes tell clients how much I respect their willingness to show up, particularly when they’re uncertain about what they want to discuss. I mean that sincerely.
Allowing yourself to become curious about your experiences requires a willingness to encounter things you haven’t completely figured out yet.
For some people, therapy begins with a specific problem they want to address. For others, it’s an opportunity to examine their relationships, values, identities, and the ways they move through the world.
Both are legitimate reasons to seek help.
If you’re considering therapy and wondering what you’re supposed to talk about, you can begin with that very question.
You don’t need to know where to start, and you certainly don’t need to have everything figured out before your first appointment.
That’s something you and your therapist can explore together.
At NY Wellness Counseling Services, we offer individual online therapy for people interested in understanding themselves, improving their relationships, and exploring the experiences shaping their lives. Whether you’re dealing with a specific mental health concern or simply want a deeper understanding of yourself, our approach emphasizes curiosity, connection, and meaningful personal growth.
If you’re thinking about starting therapy but aren’t sure what to say, you can schedule a free initial consultation. You don’t need to prepare a perfect explanation for why you’re reaching out. We can begin the conversation wherever you are.
