One Assumption Worth Making: Everyone is Carrying Something

Everyone is carrying something we cannot see. A therapist reflects on suffering, empathy, and why that simple assumption can change how we see others.

I recently found myself in the middle of a debate between two friends about religion. One friend was questioning his faith after going through experiences that caused him tremendous suffering. The other was trying to help by sending Bible verses and asking questions about whether my friend had truly yielded to Jesus.

I understood that he meant well, but I asked him a simple question: “How do you think he would feel if I sent him this?”

He thought about it for a moment and said, “I think he would be pissed off.”

That exchange stayed with me because I started wondering who the explanation was really helping.

Sometimes, when another person is suffering, we become uncomfortable with the fact that we cannot explain it or make it go away. We want to find a reason. We want to understand what happened, what went wrong, or what the person could have done differently. I think we sometimes do this because explanations make us feel safer.

Imagine hearing that someone was struck by a car while walking down the street. There is something terrifying about the randomness of that. Then you learn that the driver was intoxicated. The tragedy is no less tragic, but suddenly there is an explanation. We can identify what went wrong, and perhaps the world feels slightly more predictable again.

I wonder whether we sometimes approach emotional suffering the same way.

My friend’s religious worldview gave him a framework for understanding suffering, and seeing someone pray, believe, and continue to suffer created a difficult contradiction. Perhaps trying to resolve that contradiction was as much about his own discomfort as it was about helping our friend.

The friend who was suffering eventually expressed his anger toward God in a way that was difficult for me to hear because of my own Catholic background. At the same time, I felt honored that he trusted me enough to share something that I imagine was incredibly difficult to say out loud. Moments like that remind me how important it is to create relationships where people can say the things they are afraid to say, even when hearing them may bring something up in us too.

As a therapist, I recognize the impulse to resolve things because I have experienced my own version of it. When someone is hurting, I sometimes want to find the right intervention, say the right thing, or figure out what needs to change. Over time, I’ve learned that my desire to solve someone’s pain can occasionally interfere with my ability to simply be present with it. Some things cannot be immediately explained or resolved, and thinking about that conversation eventually led me somewhere else.

We All Carry Something

I started thinking about how much suffering surrounds us and how little of it we can actually see.

I was raised Catholic, so naturally one of the images that came to mind was Jesus carrying the cross. You do not have to be Christian, or even religious, for that metaphor to make sense. There is something very human about the image of someone carrying something painfully heavy. We all seem to have some version of a cross to bear.

For one person, it might be the death of a parent. For someone else, it is a marriage that is falling apart. Someone is caring for a sick family member, while someone else cannot find a job. One person may be struggling with alcohol, while another has received a diagnosis that completely changed how they imagined their future. Someone who appears to have everything going for them may also be dealing with something that makes ordinary life incredibly hard.

Being a therapist does not exempt me from any of this. If anything, doing this work has repeatedly reminded me how many people who appear perfectly fine are carrying enormous emotional weight. I have my own things that I carry, and people close to me have theirs.

Realizing this did not make anything I was dealing with disappear, but it did ease something for me. I could look at someone I cared about who was going through tremendous difficulty and think, perhaps this is his cross. I could look at something happening in my own life that felt suffocating and recognize that this is something I am carrying right now. There was something comforting about realizing that difficulty was not unique to me.

Our Crosses and Our Privileges

Recognizing that everyone carries something also made me think differently about privilege.

Someone can have qualities or opportunities that I envy while also suffering in ways that I would never want to experience. One of the people whose situation contributed to this reflection has always been extremely outgoing and charismatic. When we were younger, he could easily become the center of attention and seemed to effortlessly attract people. That never came as naturally to me.

At the same time, there are things that seem to come naturally to me that might not come as easily to him. People tend to trust me quickly and tell me things. That has helped me tremendously in friendships, in business, and certainly in becoming a therapist.

We each have privileges, and we each have things that we carry. Having one does not somehow protect us from the other.

We also create problems when we try to weigh crosses. Obviously, there are circumstances that most of us would consider devastating. I would much rather deal with certain problems in my life than receive a cancer diagnosis or lose someone I love. Perspective matters, and sometimes thinking about what we still have can help us tolerate what we are going through.

Still, I do not know that we can ever fully understand another person’s subjective experience.

Think about a hungry baby waiting for a bottle. Five minutes for milk might feel enormous to that baby. Adults are much more complex, of course, but we sometimes do something similar with one another. We look at someone’s circumstances and decide how distressed they should be by them.

We even do it to ourselves. We tell ourselves that other people have it worse, that we should be grateful, or that what is bothering us is not really a big deal. Sometimes perspective helps. Other times, we end up feeling bad about the original problem and then feeling guilty because we think we should not feel that bad.

I can know that someone’s circumstances appear worse than mine without actually knowing what it feels like to be that person. That distinction has become increasingly important to me.

The Fraternity Nobody Asked to Join

The idea of suffering as a kind of fraternity actually started with my friend Rick.

After his father died, Rick described the strange realization that he had become part of a group of people who had experienced the loss of a parent. I do not remember whether he actually used the word “fraternity,” but I remember the idea. There was now something he understood that he had not understood in quite the same way before.

This past weekend, I heard a similar sentiment while spending time with widowers. Someone described widowhood almost like joining a fraternity that you never asked to join.

That connection made sense to me because I am a member of a fraternity. If I walk into a room and notice someone wearing my letters, I feel some connection to him. I may know absolutely nothing else about this person, but I recognize the letters, and they tell me that somewhere along the way, we went through something that connects us.

Suffering is different because there are no letters.

You cannot walk into a room and necessarily see grief. You cannot always recognize loneliness or see the person who is worried about their child, whose marriage is struggling, who has not spoken to a parent in years, or who wakes up in the morning wondering whether their life is ever going to change.

Nobody asked for membership in this fraternity. Yet sooner or later, most of us find ourselves carrying something that connects us to people whose suffering may look completely different from our own.

I find something comforting about recognizing that shared membership.

When One Cross Gets Lighter

I also do not think we carry a single cross throughout our entire lives. Sometimes one becomes lighter and something else takes its place.

There was a period when something happening inside my home felt like the biggest source of stress in my life. Then my father was diagnosed with prostate cancer, and suddenly something else became much heavier. That experience reminded me how quickly our attention can shift.

Thankfully, circumstances also change. Illness can improve, someone eventually gets the job, a relationship heals, and grief changes with time. A problem that once consumed us can become something we barely think about anymore.

But I am skeptical of the idea that we eventually arrive at some permanent place where there is nothing difficult left to carry. The people we love age. Bodies change. Relationships change. Careers change. People disappoint us, and sometimes we disappoint ourselves. Things happen that we never planned for.

There are crosses that we can do something about. There are problems we can solve, relationships we can repair, treatments we can pursue, boundaries we can establish, and circumstances we can change. There are also things that, at least for now, we simply have to carry. Accepting that distinction can sometimes bring its own kind of relief.

One Assumption Worth Making

As a therapist, I usually encourage people to be careful about assumptions. We are often remarkably confident about things we cannot possibly know. In fact, one of the things I value most in therapy is remaining curious about people instead of deciding too quickly that we understand them. That is why it feels somewhat strange for me to recommend making an assumption at all.

But I am beginning to think there may be one assumption worth making:

Everyone you meet is carrying something.

I do not mean that we should pity people or walk around imagining hidden tragedies behind every smile. I am thinking of something much quieter than that, almost a silent acknowledgment that there may be parts of someone’s life that we cannot see.

I do not know what you are carrying or how heavy it feels to you, and I do not need to know. Perhaps leaving room for that possibility gives us a little more patience with the distracted coworker, the friend who has not called back, the family member who seems irritable, or even the stranger who is not particularly pleasant to us.

We still have boundaries, and we still hold people accountable for their behavior. Recognizing that someone is carrying something does not require us to excuse everything they do. It simply reminds us that the person standing in front of us has an entire life occurring outside of our interaction with them.

Maybe I Am Doing the Same Thing

There is one complication that I do not want to ignore.

This entire reflection began, at least in part, because I woke up this morning with a familiar sense of existential dread. I have experienced that feeling enough that I have gotten better at dealing with it. I have not eliminated it, but something that might once have lingered and affected a significant portion of my day can now sometimes pass within ten or fifteen minutes.

This morning, while I was sitting with that feeling, I found myself thinking about the conversations from the day before. I thought about my friends debating suffering and religion, about Rick losing his father, about the widowers I had spent time with, and eventually about crosses and fraternities and all the things people carry without anyone else knowing.

I noticed that thinking about it this way was grounding for me.

Part of me wants to stop there and tell you that I have figured something out, but I do not know that I have. Maybe the idea that everyone is carrying something is simply my latest way of trying to make sense of a world that can sometimes feel frighteningly unpredictable.

Perhaps I am doing my own version of what my friend was doing at the beginning of this piece. He had an explanation for suffering that helped the world make sense to him, and perhaps I have created one that makes sense to me.

I tend to question things, including my own conclusions. Anything that starts to feel too certain eventually makes me suspicious. So I do not know whether this is some profound realization about suffering or simply a way for me to ease some of my own existential anxiety.

Right now, though, I believe it, and right now I find it helpful.

I do not need to experience your exact grief to understand something about grief, and I do not need your particular family problems to know what it feels like when home does not feel peaceful. I do not need your diagnosis to understand fear, and I certainly do not need to know exactly what you are carrying to acknowledge that you may be carrying something.

Maybe years from now, I will think about all of this differently. For now, there is something comforting about looking around and remembering that the people I encounter are carrying things I cannot see, just as I am carrying things that they cannot see.

That does not explain suffering or resolve it. But, at least for now, it makes some of the uncertainty surrounding it a little easier for me to carry.

Book a Free Initial Consultation

Individual Therapy in New Jersey & New York

Ready to take the next step? Let’s start this journey together!